Best chocolate chip cookie doughs
In a taste test of store-bought doughs, three brands win by a landslide.

We have embarked on a taste test tour of supermarket foods. We nibble, we score, and we share the results to help you avoid the paralysis of Brand Choice Overload. Today’s topic: chocolate chip cookie dough.
After two grueling, back-to-back yogurt standoffs, cookies were a welcome relief to our taste testers. We tried five pre-made chocolate chip cookie doughs including Pillsbury, Nestle, and other supermarket staples. Some turned out crunchy and sweet, others chewy and chocolate-y, but our staff was largely in agreement and the top three won by a landslide.
A big factor was chocolate flavor–chip-to-cookie ratio, and how much they actually tasted like good chocolate. Aesthetics also popped up in a lot of our staff’s notes (apparently, when it comes to cookies, looks do matter). However, nutritionist Marissa Lippert pointed out the trans fat (ack!) and partially hydrogenated kernel oil in the prettiest-looking cookie–Pillsbury’s.
Read more: Supermarket Standoff: Chocolate Chip Cookies








